Best putters for mid handicappers: top 10 putters to lower your handicap

It’s no secret, one of the hardest things to do in golf is to go from mid handicapper to expert. That’s why it’s important to give yourself every advantage you can on the golf course. This biggest advantage, of course, comes from the using the right equipment. From finding the right driver all the way down to getting a good putter, mid handicap players should put extra effort into finding the equipment that suits them best. Our choice for best putter for mid handicappers is the TaylorMade Spider GT putter.

To save you time, our team of golf experts reviewed dozens of the best putters out there. Furthermore, we applied a rigorous criteria to specifically select the best quality putters for mid handicappers. The final 10 putters were then reviewed in head to head matchups to determine the ranking of the 10 best golf putters for mid handicappers.

The right putter can change your short game from a hassle to a complete breeze. Our top choices have the right balance of power, control, comfort, and ease of use. Learning to golf can be challenging enough, let our experts help you pick the best standing putter for your game.

TLDR: Our top choice is the TaylorMade Spider GT putter, for its surprising combination of power and control, as well as an ease of use and grip that makes it a joy to use.

Short on time? Here are the best putters for mid handicappers out right now:

  1. Best Overall – TaylorMade Spider GT
  2. Best Alignment – Callaway Odyssey 11 Triple Track Putter
  3. Best Premium Putter – Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom x11
  4. Best Craftsmanship – Mizuno M Craft 6
  5. Best Customizable Features – Ping Tomcat 14
  6. Best 2-ball Putter – Callaway Odyssey 2 Ball Putter
  7. Best Value – Cobra King Stingray Putter
  8. Best Blade Putter – Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 8 Arc
  9. Best Entry Level Price – Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter
  10. Best Budget Pick – Wilson Harmonized M5 Putter

Best Putter for mid handicappers – Full Analysis

TaylorMade Spider GT

Best Overall

#1- best putters for mid handicappers
#1 Spider GT – Best putters for mid handicappers


Over the past few years, TaylorMade made has become one of the biggest brands in putters. A big reason for this is its flagship putter, the Spider GT series. These large and forgiving mallet putters are showing up in the bags of many golf pros, such as Dustin Johnson and Jason Day. The spider GT is not only a great choice for mid handicap golfers, but golfers of all ages and abilities.

Pros – Why we like it

  • This putter’s stability and consistency are unmatched. Its lightweight aluminum and steel construction allows you to strike a putt from any angle with almost no pushback.
  • The Pure Roll face insert uses aluminum beams set at a 45 degree angle, significantly improving top spin. This gives your balls a consistent roll, keeping your putts on their target line.
  • The lightweight aluminum and steel build means that the putter feels comfortable and light in your hand.
  • The Spider GT boasts a streamlined, compact style. It combines the performance of a modern putter with a more traditional look.
  • The spider GT maintains its sleek look with a simple and unobtrusive alignment.
  • With the adjustable hosel configuration, you can hit an arc putting stroke or straight through shot. Just adjust the hosel to fit your game play style.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • The spider GT putter is a high end putter. This makes it more expensive than some budgets can accommodate. A slightly more budget friendly version of this putter is the Taylormade Spider X putter.
  • Its default putter grip may be a bit smaller than some players would like. Some players may prefer larger putter grip that is easier on their hands.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

The Spider GT is our top pick for mid handicappers. Despite its lightweight and streamlined construction, the Spider GT offers top of the line stability and consistency. It also has a great look that will stand out on any golf course.

The adjustable putter head allows golfers to hit either arc stroke or head-on putting stroke. This is unique for mallet style putters, which usually make you hit the golf ball with a straight stroke.

While some players might want a golf putter with a larger grip, it’s easy to switch out these grips to customize your club.

Overall, the Spider GT is one of the best putters we’ve ever tried.

Callaway Odyssey 11 Triple Track Putter

Best Alignment


The Triple Track Putter is part of the very popular Odyssey putter series from Callaway. These putters are easy to identify due to their “Triple Track” technology, which consists of three prominent lines on the putter head.

This alignment system is a standout feature that makes it incredibly easy for you to line up head-on shots. It’s based off of a theory called Vernier hyper acuity, which is the same visual technology used to land planes on aircraft carriers.

This alignment system, as well as the overall quality construction and performance of these putters, make them some of the best putters out there.

Pros – Why we like it

  • Using this putter is like bringing a training aid onto the golf course, great if you want a more consistent stroke.
  • The alignment system is incredibly simple to set up, just match the lines on the putter with the ones on a Callaway golf ball.
  • Our tests show that their system does work, and Callaway claims that it can help increase your accuracy up to 11%.
  • The club head lines up beautifully square, and hits very sturdy with very little face rotation. This makes it a great mallet style putter for hitting the ball head-on.
  • The microhinge start insert provides consistent topspin and roll when striking.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • Some people may prefer to use an arc stroke, but this putter is designed only for a straight back and forward shot.
  • Some people may prefer not to rely on alignment aids, and may find it distracting.
  • The system requires using a special lined ball from Callaway, and may slow down the pace of play when setting-up.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

This club is a great putter for any player that struggles with their alignment. The mallet construction combines amazingly with its alignment technology and face control, to produce an offset putter that’s easy and consistent for players to use.

Due to their ease of swing, we recommend these mallet putters for players of nearly all levels of play. The straight back motion of these putters is easier to learn and master than a traditional blade style putter.

Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom x11

Best Premium Putter


Titleist clubs have a well deserved reputation for being a premium brand. Their “no compromises” approach to quality makes them favorite clubs of many golf pros. In fact, over half of all players on the PGA tour use have at least one titlist club in their bag.

These clubs may be used by many professionals, but how accessible are they for the average player? The truth is that many players could benefit from using a club of this caliber. The Phantom x11 shows that Titlist Scotty Cameron putters are a great choice regardless of skill level.

This Scotty Cameron putter has a high MOI offset putter designed specifically of a straight on putting stroke. This makes them unbelievably simple for many players to use. While this putter may be out of budget for some, players looking for a premium brand should consider adding this club to their rotation.

Pros – Why we like it

  • This mallet style putter has the biggest club head in the Scotty Cameron line. Combined with expertly balanced weighting and a high MOI, this club is the most forgiving putter we’ve tested so far.
  • The steel reinforced putter head resists twisting at impact, ensuring that your club face hits the ball straight on.
  • The alignment is a simple line on the club head, which is convenient yet unobtrusive when lining up your shots.
  • The “Pistolo Plus” grip, developed by Scotty Cameron in conjunction with Golf Pride, keeps your upper hand in place and provides a comfortable and soft feel.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • This golf club is the most expensive out of all the clubs we tested. Some golfers may want a more budget friendly golf putter.
  • The large club head and high MOI design may take some adjusting for some golfers.
  • This club is mainly suited for a straight back and forward golf stroke, golfers who prefer an arc stroke may want a blade style putter.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

The Phantom X11 is an impressive putter suited for all skill levels. This is one of the best golf putters available for a player that wants a Titleist quality club.

As a mid handicapper, you want a putter that not only has a soft feel, but one that is forgiving on your putting stroke. The Phantom X11 is the most forgiving putter that we’ve ever tried.

Its well crafted and steel reinforced head resists bending and makes it easy to hit head on. This is the highest MOI club that Titleist makes, and its swing momentum makes putting easier than ever before.

Mizuno M Craft 6

Best Craftsmanship

Overview and Features

Mizuno is a Japanese golf club company with a strong reputation for quality and craftsmanship. While they’re best known for their forged golf irons, their M-craft putter line shows that they can make impressive putters as well.

Mizuno is famous for their superior craftsmanship. They forge their golf clubs from 1025 mild carbon steel, and then CNC mill them by hand to shape them. This ensures precision and consistency in their construction, and a finish that provides great performance. The result is a club that allows you to strike your ball with soft feel and great topspin for a consistent roll.

While Mizuno makes several types of putters, we consider the M.6 mallet putters to be their best for mid handicap players. This is due to their slightly heavier club head, which provides increased stability and swing accuracy.

Pros – Why we like it

  • The forging and precision milling process gives this milled steel putter a firm, responsive feel similar to their forged irons.
  • Mizuno putters have a slightly heavier weight than standard putters, which allows for an accurate putting stroke with controlled distance.
  • They make a pleasing sound when striking the ball.
  • These mallet putters work great for a straight forward stroke with no arc, which we highly recommend for most mid handicap golfers.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • Any golfer who often hits short may want to use a lighter putter.
  • Golfers who don’t like a mallet style may need a different type of putter.
  • There are higher MOI options out there for players who want an even more forgiving club.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

Golfers looking for something different will appreciate Mizuno’s unique approach to crafting putters. The carbon steel forging and and hand CNC milling process is something that only Mizuno offers.

The mallet head and heavy weighting will help ensure a controlled and steady putter swing. These putters hit true and accurate, and have great distance control.

These forged putters hit with a satisfying feel and sound that makes them a pleasure to use. This responsive feel will certainly be appreciated by those familiar with Mizuno’s well known and highly endorsed iron set.

The bottom line is that Mizuno now makes some of the best putters for mid handicappers out there.

Ping Heppler Tomcat 14

Best Customizable Features


The Ping Heppler Tomcat 14 is a great midrange putter with several customizable features. Named after the late Ping employee Rick Heppler, these mallet putters are set using a precision aluminum casting process. They boast a high MOI and an alignment system that’s great for creating a clean straight swing.

This putter is made with an eye catching copper and black scheme. The top of the head has two runway-style sets of dots. These dots work as an effective alignment that guides your putter for better strokes.

This putter has several adjustable parts, which is great for players who want a golf putter customized to their exact specifications. The length of the putter length adjustable between 32″ and 36″, making it suitable for almost all heights and body types. There are also several grips to choose from as well, which is great for players who may need a specialized grip.

Pros – Why we like it

  • The high MOI of this mallet style putter makes it a very forgiving club. With very little twisting on hit, it’s very hard to mishit when using this putter.
  • The customizable features are a nice touch, and ensure that this club can be fit for players with almost any physical needs.
  • Slightly less expensive than many of the top putters, this may better fit for some golfers’ budgets.
  • The flat putter face is designed and optimized to make a satisfying sound when it makes contact with the ball.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • While less expensive than the top putters on this list, it still may be unappealing to more price conscious consumers.
  • This club is very firm, and some golfers may prefer a club with a softer feel.
  • We would prefer a milled putter face for added topspin and an even more consistent roll.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

The adjustability of the Ping Tomcat 14 makes it one of the best putters for mid handicappers who value customizability. This offset putter is a very solid pick, and a great value. It’s look, sound, and feel will appeal to many players.

Check Price: Ping Heppler Tomcat 14

Callaway Odyssey 2 ball ten triple track putter

Best Two-Ball Putter


Back in 2001 the Callaway Odyssey series introduced 2-ball golf putters, and sparked a revolution in the golfing world. This is the club that helped popularize mallet putters, allowing them to shake their reputation as clunky and oversized.

The rest is history, but these 2-ball putters still deserve their reputation as being some of the best clubs out there. The Odyssey 2-ball is named for the two white disks that sit on top of the club head. When lined up behind a golf ball, these putters give the appearance of three balls in a row, which is a simple yet effective alignment tool that will have you sinking more putts.

The newest version of this putter has a sleeker head shape, which makes alignment as easy as it has ever been. The putter’s back weighting gives it a super high MOI that resists any face turn on impact. Finally, the wide face has a microhinge insert that gives a firm feel and topspin for a consistent roll and great distance control.

Pros – Why we like it

  • The two-ball alignment system is simple and efficient. It holds up as a great tool to improve your consistency and aim.
  • The forgiving head design helps you avoid mishits and bad shots.
  • The high MOI design helps to reduce twisting on impact, making it a great choice for straight back and forward hitting.
  • The microhinge insert adds lots of topspin, and helps the ball roll consistently over longer distances, overcoming many imperfections in the putting green.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • The price point for this putter is on the high end.
  • Players that wish to hit more of an arc stroke may want to consider other putters.
  • The head on this putter is very large and may take some adjustment from some golfers.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

The Odyssey 2-ball putter is classic style that still hits as well as any putter out there. Years of improvement and iteration on this design have made it better hitting and more consistent than ever. It’s mallet head and high MOI build make it one of the best putters for mid handicappers.

Cobra King Stingray Putter

Best Value


Cobra, now a subsidiary of Puma, has been making golf clubs for nearly 50 years. However, their recent putters are drawing tons of new attention for their innovation and great design.

Their Stingray putter has an oversized mallet style with a stainless steel body. This high MOI design delivers high consistency on putting swings, and their adjustable weight system makes fine tuning your club head’s balance a snap.

Specializing in a straight back, straight forward type of shot, this putter has great face control and a forgiving shot. Its SIK face technology allows for a consistent strike regardless of the club’s angle at the point of contact.

Pros – Why we like it

  • This club’s price point is lower than some of the top ranked putters on this list, making it a good value for more budget conscious shoppers.
  • The SIK face technology allows for similar hits (and consistent roll), regardless of the angle of impact when striking the golf ball.
  • The high moi mallet style putter head delivers solid alignment and and satisfying consistency.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • While less expensive than the top putters on this list, it still may be unappealing to more price conscious consumers.
  • This offset putter only allows for straight on hitting, players that want an arc stroke should look elsewhere.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

The Cobra King Stingray putter is a great value and has everything you need in a good mallet putter. The SIK face technology can improve the hitting of players that have trouble timing their swing.

Additionally, this club’s high moi design does a great job at resisting twisting on impact, and the broad mallet head makes this putter a very forgiving choice for mid handicappers.

Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 8 Arc

Best Blade Putter


You may have noticed that every previous entry on this list is a mallet putter. Given their easy and forgiving playstyle, almost all of our best putters for mid handicappers are mallet putters. The Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 8 Arc is the exception to the rule.

While most blade putters are designed for a more gentle arc, the Soft 8 Arc is one of the few blade putters designed for a straight back straight forward shot. This allows for players to hit a simple shot straight on shot with lots of forgiveness.

Furthermore, the Soft 8 Arc putter uses SOFT technology CNC milling on its face. This milling becomes less coarse at the toe and heel of the putter, allowing your hits to feel the same no matter where they’re struck on the club face.

Pros – Why we like it

  • The price point is lower than many of the putters on this list, making it a great value choice for cost conscious shoppers.
  • This is a great option for players who want a blade putter that that can hit straight on.
  • The SOFT technology creates a forgiving putter with a soft hitting feel.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • Mallet style putters still are a better choice many players who want a straight back, straight forward shot.
  • This is not a high MOI putter, so the face may twist some when it makes contact with the ball.
  • It has no alignment system.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

While we still prefer mallet putters for most mid handicappers, there may be players out there who simply prefer blade putters. For those players looking to make putting easier on themselves, we recommend the Soft 8 Arc.

Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter

Best Entry Level Price


Wilson has a reputation for making high value clubs at a great price point. The Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter, their version of a mallet putter, proves that this reputation is right on.

While many brands at this price point show signs of reduced quality, the Infinite Bucktown Putter maintains a great value. This golf putter not only boasts high quality material and face milling, but shows no signs of the cheap shortcuts found on the finish of some cheaper club heads.

This makes the club a great putter for entry-level players who don’t want to pay for a fancier club at a higher price point.

Pros – Why we like it

  • For the price point, the club still maintains a high quality of materials.
  • The double milled face provides a nice feel and reasonable amount of control.
  • Their counterbalance technology gives the putter a nice balanced shot.
  • Their anti-glare finish is a nice touch and helps you to see the sight lines better.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • This is a great entry level putter, but higher level putters will offer more MOI, control, balance, and forgiveness.
  • The head cover is fairly cheap and poor quality.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

Any player that’s in the market for an entry level putter should have a look at this one. The club head gives a nice, balanced shot while the milled face gives it a soft touch. This putter is a very solid value, and many players could certainly do worse with their first set of clubs.

Wilson Harmonized M5 Putter

Best Super Budget Pick


The Wilson Harmonized M5 Putter is the least expensive putter in the top ten. It’s a reasonable choice for someone looking to get into golf as cheaply as possible. While it may be a step back from other putters on this list, it still represents a good value for people not yet willing to spend on an expensive putter.

Pros – Why we like it

  • The price point of this standing putter makes it accessible to almost all players.
  • The mallet head provides a wide sweet spot for a fairly forgiving hit.
  • The micro-injected polymer face provides a soft feel for the putter face
  • It comes with a larger putter grip, which will suit many new players.

Cons – Drawbacks to consider

  • This club only comes in one length: 34″.
  • Players wanting to progress their game will eventually outgrow this putter.
  • Control and stability may be a bit lacking compared to other options on this list.
  • Only available for right handed putters.

Why we recommend it for mid handicappers

Occasional golfers should consider this putter if they want an inexpensive option that will save them money. The mallet style of this putter, combined with the soft face and wide grip, will suit many entry level golfers.

Top putters for mid handicappers – A quick comparison table

Golf ClubLowest PriceClub TypeBiggest ProBiggest Con
Taylormade Spider GT$300High MOIBest striking and topspinDefault grip could be larger
Callaway Odyssey 11 Triple Track Putter$300High MOIGreat alignment systemHave to set up alignment each hit
Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom x12$400High MOIMost forgivingHighest Price
Mizuno M Craft 6$300High MOIFully forged Club’ss a bit heavier than average
Ping Tomcat 14$250High MOIGreat customizabilityMay be too firm for some
Callaway Odyssey 2 Ball Ten Putter$300High MOIUnique 2-ball alignmentClub head may be too large for some
Cobra King Stingray Putter$201MalletVery consistent strikingCannot hit an arc stroke
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 8 Arc$150BladeSteady blade designSome players may prefer a mallet
Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter$130MalletAccessible price and good valueDoesn’t excel at any one thing
Wilson Harmonized M5 Putter$60MalletCheapest entry priceMay need to upgrade later

How to choose the best putter for you

While we can bring our research and our favorite picks to you, ultimately you’re the one that needs to decide what putter suits you best. The truth is that there are many good putters out there. Ultimately, you have to make your own decision based on your own personal needs and preferences.

Here are some things to keep in mind when deciding on your putter:

Identify your play style

First, take an inventory of how you approach your golf game. How exactly do you like to play your putts? Do you use a straight forward putt, or do you use an arc stroke? If you’re a mid handicapper, what are your strengths and weaknesses? These are the types of questions that you need to ask yourself as you research your putter choices.

Decide what features are most important

Once you’ve considered how you play, next decide what features in a golf club would best compliment your play. Do you like an alignment system that can help you hit head-on? Do you want a soft feel or firm feel when you hit the ball? How much MOI do you want in a putter? Make sure you prioritize your favorite features first.

Determine your budget

Next, determine what budget constraints and preferences you have. Are you interested in investing in high end equipment, or would you like to save more money? Do you need a golf club that will last a year or two, or do you want something that will serve you for a long time? We purposefully included a wide range of price points in our list, to ensure that everyone can select a quality putter.

Our selection criteria – how we select putters for mid handicappers

When testing so many different putters, we needed a system to pick out the best of the best. To do this, our team of experts prioritized our most important criteria when selecting the right putter. Then we used this criteria to create a simple and clear system to pick the best putters out there.

Our criteria for selecting putters are:

High MOI

High MOI is one of our most important criteria when selecting the best putters for mid handicappers. The MOI, or “Moment of intertia” is the momentum that a club has right when it hits the ball. Clubs with high MOI tend resist face twisting when the ball is hit off center. This helps you to prevent mishits, and resist pushback from the ball.

High MOI designs are often found on face balanced putters. Face balanced putters are built for a straight-back straight-through swing, and are very effective when combined with a high MOI. See our list of best face balanced putters for golf clubs that have a great straight-back straight-forward putting stroke.

Forgiveness when hitting the golf ball

Forgiving putters simply work better for most golfers. A forgiving golf club will hit well even for newer players, or for players having a off day. Mallet putters tend to be the most forgiving, due to their broad face and large “sweet spot” in the middle of the club head.

Forgiving clubs also tend to have a lot of topspin. A club that easily generates topspin will hit the ball true over longer distances and resist any imperfections in the putting green.

Forgiveness is especially important for players that tend to mishit frequently. Our list of best putters for high handicappers has very forgiving putters due to high handicap players tendency to mishit.

Ease of Use

One of the most important considerations for ease of use is a club’s alignment. Many golfers find it easier to hit the ball when their club has a good alignment system. A good alignment system can really help players to line up their shots and sink more putts.

Beginners will especially appreciate a club’s alignment features. Our list of best putters for beginners all have very simple and useful alignment features.

Mallet putters vs blade putters

While the preference for mallet versus blade putters is entirely personal, we believe that most high handicap players would be best off using a mallet style putter.

This comes down to some key differences between the two types:

Mallet Putter

Over the past 20 years, mallet style putters have absolutely exploded in popularity. Given their high MOI and large, forgiving club faces, it’s easy to see why. These putters are generally meant to be hit with a very straight shot, which is much easier for players to learn and execute. The larger club heads not only provide extra momentum on the shot, they also provide space for nice alignment systems.

Blade Putter

These putters have a more traditional style, with a slimmer head that requires a bit more skill and practice to master. Blade style putters have slimmer heads, meaning that they may twist on impact. They are preferred for an arc stroke putting swing, which is generally more complicated and difficult to learn than the “straight-on” swing that mallets use.


What is the best putter for a 10 handicap?

The Taylormade Spider GT is the best putter for mid handicap players.

Which putters are most forgiving?

The Scotty Cameron Phantom x12 is the most forgiving of all the putters we’ve tested so far. Generally, large mallet putters with high MOI are the most forgiving.

What is the easiest putter to putt with?

The Callaway Odyssey 11 Triple Track Putter is the easiest putter to use, it has the easiest and best alignment system we’ve seen in a putter. It’s like bringing your favorite alignment aids to the golf course

Do I need a 34 inch or 35 inch putter?

Players 5’8 and under should get a 34 inch putter, anyone taller should get a 35 inch putter.

To summarize, these are our top putters for mid handicappers

RankGolf ClubOur ScoreVisit Website
1Taylormade Spider GT9.9/10Check Price
2Callaway Odyssey 11 Triple Track Putter9.8/10Check Price
3Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom x119.8/10Check Price
4Mizuno M Craft 69.7/10Check Price
5Ping Tomcat 149.6/10Check Price
6Callaway Odyssey 2 Ball Ten Putter9.6/10Check Price
7Cobra King Stingray Putter9.5/10Check Price
8Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft 8 Arc9.3/10Check Price
9Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter9.0/10Check Price
10Wilson Harmonized M5 Putter8.7/10Check Price

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *